CARROLL COUNTY, Ill. – Prosecutors have rested their case as the defense claims lack of evidence in day two of jury trial against a former deputy charged in the 2024 death of Jackson Kradle in Carroll County.
Matthew Herpstreith, 45, of Savanna, is facing several charges including Reckless Homicide, a Class 3 Felony, as well as Reckless Conduct, and Obstruction of Justice, both Class 4 Felonies.
LAW ENFORCEMENT CAREER
MATTHEW HERPSTREITH
Carroll County Sheriff’s Office
June 2018 – July 2024
City of Savanna Police Department
Aug. 2017 – Jan. 2024
Source: ILETSB
Herpstreith is accused of not keeping a proper lookout and being inattentive to the roadway after consuming alcohol since late afternoon the prior day, when he allegedly drove his Dodge Ram 1500 pickup truck into and over Kradle in the early morning hours of July 28, 2024.
An autopsy revealed Kradle had been fatally struck by a single vehicle, moving at a high speed, shortly before the time Herpstreith reported finding a body.
In March 2025, Special Prosecutor Charles Colburn formally charged Herpstreith.
Herpstreith has since pleaded Not Guilty.
On Tuesday, eight witnesses were called to the stand for cross examination with the questions primarily focused on the actions of Herpstreith in the hours leading up to Kradle’s death.
The witnesses who took the stand included Herpstreith’s passenger Amy Hubble, as well as forensic pathologist Dr. Mark Peters, who performed the autopsy.
Witnesses.
KAYLA RUSSELL
Carroll County Dispatcher Kayla Russell testified she has been employed by the Sheriff’s Office since 2013.
On July 27, 2024, Russell said she worked a day shift before going to a retirement party for Kradle’s aunt Cindy Sisler being held at the Copper Cow in Mt. Carroll, where she said Herpstreith and Hubble were also in attendance.
After leaving the Copper Cow, Russell testified she went to a house party hosted by Cindy Sisler’s son Jayson Houston in Mt. Carroll, where she said Herpstreith and Hubble were also in attendance.
Russell testified that alcohol was served at both parties, and that both Herpstreith and Hubble were ‘drinking,’ but said she didn’t know what was in their cups.
At Houston’s house, Russell said she saw Herpstreith carrying a tequila bottle, and that he later ‘took a shot’ but couldn’t confirm if it was alcohol.
After leaving Houston’s house, Russell testified she, Herpstreith and Hubble ended up going to the Sand Burr bar near Thomson, and then the Sippi Side bar in Savanna until it closed at around 2 a.m.
From the Sippi Side bar, Russell testified she rode in Hubble’s vehicle to Hubble’s home in Savanna where Herpstreith later picked up both of them in his truck.
Upon Herpstreith’s arrival, Russell said she got into the backseat on the passenger side while Hubble got into the front seat.
Russell testified that Herpstreith first drove them to Casey’s before going to one of his properties where he and Hubble left the truck for about 10 to 15 minutes while she waited from inside the truck.
From Herpstreith’s property, Russell said he drove them to her home in Mt. Carroll to drop her off and help her get to bed.
Russell admitted she was intoxicated and that Herpstreith’s level of intoxication was ‘comparable’ to hers at the time he dropped her off. Furthermore, Russell said she saw three liquid beverages inside the truck while Herpstreith was driving, but couldn’t confirm if their cups contained alcohol or not.
AMY HUBBLE
Now-former Carroll County Dispatcher, and paramedic, Amy Hubble was the passenger in Herpstreith’s truck when they reported finding a body in the road.
Hubble testified she was a dispatcher with the Sheriff’s Office for seven years, and has been a licensed paramedic for 12 years.
While Russell was waiting in the truck at Herpstreith’s property, Hubble said she was playing a game in the bar area as he made her a drink with whiskey that she brought with her on the trip to Russell’s house.
After leaving Russell’s house, in the passenger seat of Herpstreith’s truck, Hubble testified she was playing music with the window rolled down smoking a cigarette as they headed northbound on Route 78.
Within about five minutes after leaving Russell’s house, Hubble testified she heard Herpstreith say ‘deer in road’ as he swerved into the southbound lane.
Hubble said she turned to look at the highway and saw, what she described as, “white and some color.”
Seconds later, Hubble testified she heard Herpstreith say, ‘I think that’s a body in the road.’ And that he immediately turned the truck around and stopped.
After parking the truck, and realizing it was in fact a body, Hubble said she immediately got out of the truck to render aid and Herpstreith called dispatch.
While assessing the body, Hubble said she observed a faint pulse and could see a large laceration to the head with ‘blood and brain matter’ on the highway.
When asked if there was anything she could do to save his life, Hubble answered, “No.”
Upon arrival of Mt. Carroll Police Officer Scott Marth, Hubble said he initially assessed the body with her and let her borrow his flashlight to inspect the suspected blood and ‘brain matter.’
Afterward, Hubble said Marth walked and talked with Herpstreith before she heard Herpstreith ask, ‘Do you want us to stay on scene or go on home?’
Hubble testified she left with Herpstreith but couldn’t remember if the body was in front of, or behind, the truck before they pulled away from the scene.
At around 3:55 a.m., Hubble said Herpstreith dropped her off at her home in Savanna, and then went to work a shift as dispatcher less than two hours later.
When she arrived for work at the Sheriff’s Office shortly before 6 a.m., Hubble said she learned Sheriff Kloepping was ‘mad’ she and Herpstreith didn’t stay on the scene to provide statements to police.
Hubble testified she sent a text message, that she later deleted, to Herpstreith that morning saying, ‘We need to get on the same page for statements.’
Explaining why she deleted the message, Hubble said she was worried about, ‘getting in trouble from the boss,’ for not staying on scene to give statements.
CINDY SISLER
Retired Carroll County Dispatcher, and Kradle’s aunt, Cindy Sisler testified she spent 27 years with the Sheriff’s Office, and it was her retirement party that took place the evening prior to Kradle’s death.
Cindy testified that Herpstreith was consuming vodka at the Copper Cow, and knew so because he had approached her asking her to try his drink, telling her that, ‘They make them stronger downstairs.’
At Houston’s party, Cindy said Herpstreith brought with him a bottle of tequila, vodka, and blue punch. And that he was drinking from a cup containing blue liquid, as seen on video footage captured at the party.
JAYSON HOUSTON
Kradle’s cousin, and Cindy’s son Jayson Houston corroborated Cindy’s testimony testifying that Herpstreith brought a bottle of tequila and vodka to his party.
Furthermore, Houston testified that Herpstreith drank at least one cup of vodka with Red Bull at his house, saying he knew so because Herpstreith had made a comment about the strength of the vodka.
MATTHEW KIPPING
The case agent assigned to supervise the state police investigation into the death of Kradle was Matthew Kipping, who testified he has worked with ISP since 2013.
Kipping testified that ISP looked at several vehicles in the course of their investigation, and was given verbal consent from Herpstreith to inspect his truck.
According to Kipping, Herpstreith was ‘cooperative’ with their investigation, but was not initially forthcoming about taking his truck to a car wash immediately after leaving the scene of a body.
When cross examined by the defense, Kipping said he never received any information that Herpstreith was either intoxicated, tired or inattentive.
Kipping also testified that ISP’s accident reconstruction unit was not used to investigate Kradle’s death.
DR. MARK PETERS
Forensic pathologist Dr. Mark Peters, who performed an autopsy on Kradle, testified he has been practicing medicine since 1997, and that he currently performs autopsies for 10 counties in Illinois.
Dr. Peters testified that Kradle was either crawling or laying face down when he was ran over by a vehicle moving at a speed of at least 40 miles per hour.

Dr. Peters added that the impact of the vehicle’s undercarriage caused severe lacerations to Kradle’s head and buttocks, and that his body was either dragged or tumbled causing fatal blunt trauma to the head.
The severe lacerations were generated by an upward force in a single direction, according to Dr. Peters, which he says is indicative of impact with a vehicle.
Furthermore, the depth of the lacerations rules out the theory Kradle may have simply fallen off a truck that was traveling on highway, according to Dr. Peters.
Prosecutors cited Hubble’s testimony that she had observed a faint pulse when asking Dr. Peters if it were possible Kradle was alive at the time he was initially assessed.
Dr. Peters replied, “Yes,” a faint pulse indicates Kradle may have still been alive when Hubble was assessing him.
VIDEO EVIDENCE
Prosecutors played video footage of Herpstreith and Hubble with a group of people, including Russell, inside Sippi Side bar in Savanna at around 12:45 a.m.
Another video played by prosecutors showed Hubble buying a pack of cigarettes at Casey’s in Savanna at 2:21 a.m.
From 4:03 a.m. to 4:08 a.m., Herpstreith is positively identified on security camera footage washing the undercarriage and bottom half of his truck at the Savanna Car Wash in Savanna.
State rests.
Following prosecutors’ announcement that they rest their case, the defense moved to request for a Directed Verdict – a ruling entered by a trial judge after determining that there is no legally sufficient evidentiary basis for a reasonable jury to reach a different conclusion.
The defense accused prosecutors of using ‘sensationalist speculation’ to build a case against Herpstreith that contains ‘no evidence of recklessness.’
“To force my client to stand trial with this evidence would be an injustice,” said defense attorney Joseph Nack.
“He had three, maybe four drinks over 12 hours… There is nothing here to establish recklessness.” Nack added.
Prosecutor Charles Colburn responded, “There is open alcohol in the vehicle and they are out rogue driving. There is no evidence of braking and there is no other traffic coming to distract them.”
“There is no reason to have ran over Kradle unless he’s not paying attention,” Colburn added. “Then immediately going to a car wash to destroy evidence.”
According to Colburn, Herpstreith leaving the scene to wash his truck shows a ‘consciousness of guilt.’
Judge Peska denied the defense’s motion to end the trial with a directed verdict.
What’s next?
The defense is expected to call five witnesses to the stand Wednesday for day three of jury trial that is set to begin at 9 a.m. in Carroll County court.
SHARE THIS STORY IN YOUR COMMUNITY.
CLICK HERE TO VIEW CASE TIMELINE.
CASE BACKGROUND:
Discover more from KJB REPORTS
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.







