‘Crime and cover up’: State puts focus on physical evidence at first day of trial in Kradle homicide

CARROLL COUNTY, Ill. – Prosecutors placed the focus on the physical evidence at the opening day of a jury trial against a former deputy charged in the 2024 death of Jackson Kradle in Carroll County, Illinois.

Matthew Herpstreith, 45, of Savanna, is facing several charges including Reckless Homicide, a Class 3 Felony, as well as Reckless Conduct, and Obstruction of Justice, both Class 4 Felonies.

Herpstreith is accused of not keeping a proper lookout and being inattentive to the roadway after consuming alcohol since late afternoon the prior day, when he allegedly drove his Dodge Ram 1500 pickup truck into and over Kradle in the early morning hours of July 28, 2024.

An autopsy revealed Kradle had been fatally struck by a single vehicle, moving at a high speed, shortly before the time Herpstreith reported finding a body.

In March 2025, Special Prosecutor Charles Colburn formally charged Herpstreith.

Herpstreith has since pleaded Not Guilty.

On Monday, nine witnesses were called to the stand to be cross examined by each side with questions primarily focused on the scene of Kradle’s body, and the process of documenting, collecting and securing evidence from the scene.



Opening statements.

PROSECUTORS
Led by Charles Colburn

Prosecutors told the jury that, ‘this is a case about a crime and cover up.’ Adding, ‘the cover up was also a crime.’

Admitting Kradle was intoxicated and didn’t make good decisions the night he died, and should have received discipline from his parents, prosecutors argue the actual consequences were, ‘far greater.’

Prosecutors allege Herpstreith was consuming alcohol at a retirement party for Kradle’s aunt before attending ‘after parties’ where alcohol was served, and other bars, in the hours leading up to fatally driving into and over Kradle with his truck.

Furthermore, prosecutors told the jury Herpstreith lied to investigators the morning of the incident, which subsequently sent law enforcement on a ‘wild goose chase.’

In their closing remarks, prosecutors said they were confident that, ‘the only just verdict in this case is Guilty.’

DEFENSE
Led by Joseph Nack

The defense urged the jury to, ‘listen to all the evidence,’ claiming prosecutors had no evidence of intoxication and no point of impact on the vehicle, and that Herpstreith had been ‘100% cooperative with police.’

Countering the prosecutors’ narrative, the defense told the jury Herpstreith was driving in the dark when he saw something in the road and ‘swerves to the left,’ citing the autopsy that shows there were no tire marks on Kradle’s body.

Admitting Herpstreith took his truck to a car wash after leaving the scene, the defense argues he was ensuring there wasn’t any splatter on the truck from driving over it on the road, rather than trying to destroy evidence of wrongdoing.

In their closing remarks, the defense told the jury, ‘this is a horrible tragedy but it was not [Herpstreith’s] fault.’



Witnesses.

MADELINE STEPHENS

The first witness called to the stand was Kradle’s then-girlfriend Madeline Stephens, who is the last known person to have spoken with him the morning he died.

Stephens testified Kradle was upset, and intoxicated from alcohol and cannabis, when he left his father’s Mt. Carroll home on foot around 2:30 a.m., about an hour prior to Herpstreith reporting he found a body.

When asked about how long it normally takes to walk from Kradle’s father’s home to the site of the collision, Stephens said it takes about 30 to 40 minutes.

The defense inquired about a party Kradle and Stephens attended prior to arriving at Kradle’s father’s house around 2 a.m., and what they were doing.

Stephens testified that she and Kradle were with about two dozen other people who were under legal age but consuming alcohol and cannabis at Kradle’s grandfather’s farm located just north of Mt. Carroll, near the site where Kradle’s body was found.

According to Stephens, Kradle’s parents permitted the consumption of alcohol at the farm. She also testified that she informed Kradle’s father he had left the house.

The defense highlighted inconsistent statements made by Stephens regarding the clothing Kradle was wearing at the farm, versus the clothing he was wearing when he walked out of the house for the last time.

Stephens initially told police Kradle was wearing a black shirt and blue shorts when he left the house. However, when testifying Monday, Stephens said Kradle was wearing only blue shorts but no shirt.

Kradle was found in the road wearing only blue shorts, but no shirt or shoes.

Stephens cited her level of intoxication to explain why she was uncertain regarding the clothing in her initial interview with police.

SCOTT MARTH

Mt. Carroll Police Officer Scott Marth was the first member of law enforcement to arrive on scene at around 3:36 a.m.

Marth testified he was located at the police station in Mt. Carroll when he received a call about a body found in the roadway.

Upon arrival, Marth testified he knew Herpstreith, and that he observed him and Amy Hubble standing in front of the truck parked on the south side of the body.

Marth said he observed the body in the northbound lane with blood on the right side of the head area, and testified that Hubble had rolled the body over to face up position prior to his arrival.

Illustration of a pedestrian lying on a roadway with a red blood-like mark and an Illinois Route 78 sign.


The interaction lasted about 5 to 6 minutes, according to Marth, before he released both of them from the scene without asking any questions about possible involvement.

Marth testified both Herpstreith and Hubble appeared to be acting ‘normal’ on scene and that he didn’t suspect them to be intoxicated, and didn’t see any damage on the truck.

JOSI ANDERSON

At around 3:46 a.m., Carroll County Sheriff’s Deputy Josi Anderson arrived on scene, but Herpstreith and Hubble were gone.

Given the fact the body was located outside city limits, Anderson testified that county would normally be the agency to decide when someone can be released.

Prosecutors played a clip from Anderson’s body-worn camera showing the squad car’s standard headlights adequately illuminating a body in the roadway at night.

DAVID MERCADO

Now-retired Carroll County Detective David Mercado testified they identified Kradle by showing a photo of his face to a person who had crashed their vehicle near Savanna earlier that morning.

According to Mercado, the Sheriff’s Office questioned a person that morning who was retrieving their vehicle from an overnight crash, thinking it could be connected.

After a brief investigation, Mercado said it was determined the two incidents were not connected but the person was able to identify the face of the body as Kradle.

Afterward, Mercado testified he met with Kradle’s father Joshua Sisler.

And when the investigation led to the need for questioning then-employees of the county, Herpstreith and Hubble, Mercado said they decided to contact Illinois State Police to take over the investigation.

SHERIFF KLOEPPING

Elected in 2019, Carroll County Sheriff Ryan Kloepping testified he was initially contacted about the incident by his Chief Deputy Ryan Lambert at around 3:40 a.m. while on a camping trip with family.

Upon arrival and observing the scene, Sheriff Kloepping said they were ‘very unsure’ about what had happened.

Sheriff Kloepping testified Herpstreith called him around 6:11 a.m. but that they didn’t discuss making any formal statements.

According to Sheriff Kloepping, Herpstreith told him he swerved around what he thought was a deer but realized it was a human body after turning around to check.

Prosecutors showed the statement Herpstreith wrote to Sheriff Kloepping at trial, which said, in part: “I went around it thinking it was a deer but something told me it wasn’t a deer so I turned around and came back and realized it was a body.”

Sheriff Kloepping said the county’s involvement with the investigation ended when the case was handed over to state police by around noon.

SGT. JEFF THEW

ISP Crime Scene Investigator Jeff Thew documented and collected evidence on scene, and later inspected Herpstreith’s truck, the day Kradle died.

After processing the scene for the initial investigation being conducted by the Sheriff’s Office, Thew testified that state police investigators asked him to inspect the undercarriage of Herpstreith’s truck for blue fabric from Kradle’s shorts.

Later that day, Thew said Herpstreith allowed him to inspect his truck where he not only found pieces of blue fabric from Kradle’s shorts, but also found pieces of biological material or blood on parts of the truck’s undercarriage.

Thew testified that test results show the suspected blood found on the truck’s undercarriage came from a human.

Furthermore, Thew said the length of biological material splatter observed on the roadway was about 24 to 25 feet, but no damage was found on the truck.



What’s next?

Day two of the jury trial is set to begin Tuesday at 9 a.m. in Carroll County court.

The trial is expected to last through Friday.


SHARE THIS STORY IN YOUR COMMUNITY.

Promotional graphic for The Death of Jackson Kradle trial, featuring portraits of Jackson Kradle and People v. Hepstreith, with daily coverage scheduled for November 16–20 at KyleJBales.com.

Discover more from KJB REPORTS

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply